On The List; Off The List

Small Associated Press story in today’s Metro Ottawa (“City recognizes Islamic holidays”), being taken from a Vancouver Sun story of yesterday:

Hamburg becomes 1st German city to recognize Islamic holidays

BERLIN – Authorities in Hamburg have become the first in Germany to officially recognize Islamic holidays so Muslim employees and students can celebrate them at home.

The decision forms part of an agreement between the north German city and local Muslim groups.

Similar agreements exist with Christian and Jewish communities in the city.

Hamburg’s mayor, Olaf Scholz, said Tuesday that he hopes the deal will serve as an example for other German cities.

Authorities estimate some 150,000 Muslims live the city of almost 2 million people.

The growing public presence of Islamic culture in Germany has sparked anger among conservatives and far-right groups.

Police in Berlin are on alert for possible violence this weekend after a small far-right party said it plans to stage protests outside mosques in the German capital.

A longer story from the English version of Der Spiegel:

Hamburg recognizes Muslim religious holidays

It may be just a symbolic gesture, but the German city-state of Hamburg has garnered widespread praise for signing an official agreement with its Muslim community that guarantees Islamic holidays, religion courses in schools and burial ritual rights.

The deal, which must still be approved by the city’s parliament, is the first of its kind in Germany. It was agreed to by representatives of Hamburg’s Muslim and Alevi communities, whose holidays will gain the same status as non-statutory Christian holidays. On these days, people who wish to observe the holiday have the right to either use a vacation day or make it up another time.

Aydan Özoguz, the deputy leader of the center-left Social Democratic Party and a federal parliamentarian from Hamburg, said that the agreement will have a concrete meaning in the everyday lives of Muslims and Alevi, a liberal branch of Islam which forms Turkey’s largest religious minority. “There is a big difference between a Muslim worker having to say to his boss, ‘I’m taking vacation,’ and being able to be more direct and say, ‘This is my religious holiday, and I would like to celebrate it, so I’ll take it off and make up the work later’,” she said.

The Hamburg agreement creates more openness and recognition not just in Hamburg, but across the country, where there has also been great interest in the initiative, Özoguz added. “I would be very happy if other states followed suit,” she added.

Few Real Changes

Indeed, praise for the deal came from across the country, including the southern state of Baden-Württemberg. “The Hamburg initiative is a strong signal for both sides — the state and Muslims — in the political debate over whether Muslims belong to Germany,” said the state’s Integration Minister Bilkay Öney.

The spokesperson for the government of the city-state of Berlin, Richard Meng, said he was also pleased that Hamburg had “opened the way for more openness and tolerance,” pointing out that the German capital had also already taken some similar measures, such as providing the right to taking Muslim holidays off for students and workers.

But the agreement is unlikely to change much in reality for the some 130,000 Muslims and Alevi living in Hamburg. Workers will still have to use their holiday time or make up work, while students have already been given important Muslim holidays off. Essentially, the deal is nothing more than a symbolic welcome and recognition of the will to achieve equal rights and recognition for Muslims and the Alevi. According to the Hamburg city government, it is a “gesture” to indicate that the city recognizes the religion.

Not the Same Rights

The biggest change will be to school religion courses. Until now, the Protestant church in Hamburg was responsible for non-denominational religion courses. But now the model will be further developed to include Muslims and Alevi in the coming five years.

Another aspect of the agreement that caused a stir among the opposition in the SPD-led state parliament is actually nothing new. Teachers are still permitted to wear headscarves, and any disputes will be decided on an individual basis. But currently there are no known cases of teachers who actually wear a headscarf to begin with.

Islamic groups also won’t be granted anything close to the same rights as Christian churches in Germany, which are recognized as statutory corporations that receive a church tax levied on members by the state. Still, the fact that the city-state has officially reached out to the Turkish-Islamic Union (DITIB), the “Schura” Association of Islamic Communities in Hamburgand the Association of Islamic Cultural Centres (VIKZ) is viewed as an important step.

With reporting by Anna Reimann

So many dimensions. Why not all religions? Might be preferable and more inclusive to have a number of statutory holidays per year, not based on any religion, contrary to what is currently the case with statutory holidays relating to Christmas and Easter. Beyond statutory holidays, people can use vacation days for any religious holidays or take time off, without salary, for religious holidays. Children being excused from school for similar holidays, with the expectation that it is the student, not the school, who will make up the time.

Mentioned the Hamburg developments to a Muslim friend, who immediately assumed that both Christians and Jews had similar rights in Canada. Corrected him–the holidays that are statutory are referenced solely to the Christian religion. Those celebrating Jewish holidays do so without similar protections as to accommodation.

Hamburg different in so many respects. City-state authority, rather than provincial authority. Mandatory religious taxation for Christians, if I am reading Der Spiegel correctly.

Seems to be always an issue as to who isn’t on the list, relative to who is. “Muslims and Alevi“. Didn’t know “Alevi” before this. How many Hindus before similar rights are enshrined? How “significant” must the minority be?

Maybe better to have no list at all.
Postscript, August 16, 2012: In addition to not being accorded any rights to religious holidays in Canada, my understanding is that Jewish business owners cannot, according to religious law, earn money on such days, even indirectly. That is why in one accounting firm I was associated with, I was paid for the Jewish holidays, plus also paid for the Christian ones. Very generous, but still regrettable. Greater equality in separating all religions from general civil entitlements.

About brucelarochelle

This entry was posted in Christianity, Germany, Islam, Judaism. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s